Friday, October 31, 2008

DO YOU KNOW THE RULES?

When I see investigations for doctors, the first thing I want to see is the medical record. Even if I don’t understand the medicine at first, I know if I am going to have a problem or not based on the records themselves.

In order to help me and help yourself, the physician must make good use of the medical record he or she has. I would urge you to know Board Rule 165.1 on the requirements for what is required for a medical record in Texas and follow the rules. Review the rules at the Board’s web site. My guess is that you are in violations of the rules as they are written.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

New Chair and New Appointment to the Acupuncture Board

Gov. Rick Perry has named Allen Cline of Austin chair of the Texas Board of Acupuncture Examiners. He also re-appointed Terry Rascoe of Temple and appointed Rachelle Webb of Austin to the board, which regulates the practice of acupuncture in the state of Texas. Their terms expire Jan. 31, 2013.
Mr. Cline is president of Turtle Dragon Health Services. He is a past member of the Texas and American associations of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine. He received a master’s degree from the New England School of Acupuncture. Cline also attended Beijing Medical University and the National Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine of China in Beijing. He replaces Terry Rascoe as chair.
Dr. Rascoe is a physician and medical director at the Northside Family Practice Clinic which is a Scott & White Regional Clinic. He is a member of the American and Texas Medical associations, American and Texas academies of Family Physicians, and the Academy of Medical Acupuncture. Rascoe received a bachelor’s degree from Baylor University and a medical degree from Texas A&M University. He is being reappointed.
Ms. Webb is a licensed acupuncturist in private practice. She is a volunteer with the Remedy Community Clinic and Wright House Wellness Center, a fundraiser for the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society and Paramount Theater Alliance. Webb attended Austin Community College and the Academy of Oriental Medicine at Austin. She replaces Hoang Ho of San Antonio.

MITIGATING FACTORS

According to the Board’s own rules, 190.14(6), the Board is to consider mitigating factors if the Board finds a physician violated the Act.

Mitigating factors are critical if you are involved in an investigation to express this information to the Board. Please do not think that engaging in mitigating factors is equal to an admission that you did something wrong. It is not. But it is all right to use the investigation as a painful learning experience to evaluate the facts of the investigation and see what, if anything, could have been done to have a better outcome. Sometimes, you see with hindsight that something else could have been done; sometimes, maybe nothing else could have been done. Maybe it is poor records, or maybe it is a system’s error. Examining all factors, especially those factors beyond just the underlying allegations can be very helpful to you during the Board’s investigation and can help even more should the investigation result in a disciplinary hearing.

Friday, October 10, 2008

180 DAYS, WHAT DOES IT MEAN?

I frequently get asked how long an investigation takes. I usually supply a lawyer answer. “It depends!”

Now the rules says an investigation should take 180 days. 22 Texas Administrative Code Section 179.6(a). However, it has been more frequent that it takes longer. So if they violate this rule, what happens? Nothing. There is no enforcement to this rule. The rule says the Board should send a letter explaining why it has taken longer than 180 days. 22 Texas Administrative Code Section 179.6(c). However, to date not one of my clients have ever received such a letter. In some cases, I have even asked for this letter from Board staff. I still have not received such a letter.

Again, there is no enforcement mechanism requirement to get this letter, other than going to District Court and filing a writ of mandamus motion. (This is basically asking the Court to direct a government agency to complete a mandatory or ministerial duty). Frankly, this would be a waste of time and resources. So why is this important? Honestly, it is not. This is one of those rule that was made only to ease complaints; but it is meaningless because the Board can go beyond the 180 days and it does not matter.

I will say the Board tries to make the official deadline. But when they don’t, they don’t. Someone under investigation just needs to be patient because you may not know when the investigation will be concluded

Monday, September 29, 2008

SIGNING AN AGREED ORDER DOES NOT MEAN ITS OVER

Once physician signs an Agreed Order to settle an investigation that does not mean the investigation is actually settled. The full Board must vote and approve the order by a majority vote. Usually every meeting one or more orders are rejected or modified by the Board members. Those Agreed Orders are not passed. The Board members usually make amendments to the Agreed Order, which is essentially a counter offer. The problems with this are many. The top three issues I find are:

1) It creates ill will. The doctor and the Board have to go through a hearing and often negotiate this with the Board staff and Board members who the met with the Informal Settlement Conference. The rejection often creates anger from the doctor.
2) Recently, the Board has not done a good job following the law. According to Texas Occupations Code Section164.0031, the Board is to expressly state why they rejected the Agreed Order. When notifying the physician of this action, TMB staff frequently does not explain what happened and why. Sometimes, they do not even know the rationale to change the Agreed Order. This leaves the doctor in the dark. Sometimes, the Board members make assumptions on the basis of the action that may be wrong.
3) The largest frustration is it appears when the Board takes this step and that it appears, from the outside, to be an arbitrary decision. This is especially the case when a Board member who has not seen any of the evidence and did not participate in the decision makes the argument to change the Order.

It would be better, in my opinion, to have a mechanism whereby if Board members have an issue with an Agreed Order it be announced prior to the meeting so that the assigned Board staff attorney and the physician have the opportunity to discuss the proposed Agreed Order before the full Board and answer whatever questions or concerns the Board member may have. Also it will give the Board members who served on the Informal Settlement Conference a chance to refresh their memories and be able to explain why they decided the way they did. This will make the process more open, the parties will have less anger and may lead to less litigation.

Friday, September 26, 2008

8th GRADE MATH

More and more I am seeing both TMB experts and Board members and staff arguing that a doctor’s medical records are deficit because the records fail to provide expressed justification or rationale for medical treatments, labs, consults and testing.

TMB is demanding that doctors justify what you are doing. Your medicine may be right, but if you don’t show the “why” some Board consultants, members and staff will find your records are deficient. I liken this to Eight Grade math. Take 144 ÷ 12 , you know it’s 12. Well in Eight Grade math, the teacher would mark you wrong because you didn’t show your work. If you showed the 144 - 144 = 0 and then you placed the 12 on top that would be right. Same outcome, as before, but this time you demostrated to the teacher how you got there.

Think about this with your medical records.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Board to Consider Standardizing Impairment Orders

At the TMB Board meeting on August 30th, there was discussion of standardizing the length, the terms and conditions of impairment orders. It may be with such cases in the future, the individual would not even go to a hearing unless the circumstance of that person’s impairment history was out of the norm. According to the discussion, the “standard” case seems to be someone who abused alcohol or drugs in medical school or residency. They recognized they had a problem and sought treatment. Under those type cases the TMB would formulate a standard agreement of maybe seven years to monitor those individuals. Typical monitoring would be with drug screening, mandated attendance at a 12 step program, required participation in a county medical society impairment committee and approved mental health care. TMB staff will have a proposal for the Board members to consider at the October meeting. Those cases that are “egregious” would be sent to a disciplinary hearing.

My Take: I think this is a reasonable idea that could be well used and certainly could speed up the process of having someone monitored by the Board. The three concerns that come to my mind are:
(1) What does “egregious” mean? Is it someone who harmed a patient while impaired, or is it a doctor who does not meet the “standard” view of how impairment cases make it to the Board? It is not clear to me at this time.
(2) What if someone wants a hearing? How is that process going to be resolved? Obviously, the TMB cannot waive someone’s due process rights, so how will that play out? It is a critical question that must be resolved and a plan is in place.
(3) The individuals who are offered such Orders need to be fully aware of the consequences of such Orders. There are a lot of pitfalls that people find once they are bound by an Order that they do not know about and, frankly, the TMB does not do an adequate job educating them on those issues until after the Order is in affect. In the staff’s defense, it is not their job to educate the licensee; it’s the licensee’s responsibility.