Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Notes from the Executive Committee of the Texas Medical Board from February 5, 2009

The biggest news and least surprising was the Board made Mari Robinson the Executive Director, removing the “interim” tag that she has carried for the past several months.

The Board also approved Dr. Moore to be the full-time Medical Director.

An issue that will dominate the Board and government in general due to the country’s economic crisis is the budget. Thus, the Board is looking at ideas to generate income for itself. Some of the ideas are as follows:

1) A proposal to have the Board offer on-line CME, in such areas as ethics and chart monitoring online. The Board does not have to be certified through a CME group to offer CME. They will have to change the rules to say the Board will accept any Board produced course. Ms. Robinson mentioned that the Board has the authority to change the language. In order to further study this, a subcommittee was formed. Those volunteering include: Dr. Margaret McNeese, Dr. Melinda McMichael, Mr. Timothy Webb, Dr. Charles Oswald and Ms. Annette Raggette.
2) License verification by hospitals, peer review committees or other states will be charged for the verification beginning Sept 2009.
3) Wall certificates – currently applicants receive a letter and an 8 x 10 piece of paper stating they are licensed. They are considering offering (not requiring) a larger, higher quality licensure certificate for a cost of between $30 - $50. This cost range is comparable to other states and Texas is one of the few states that do not offer this.
4) JP Exam questions – currently the Board drafts questions for the exam without charging. They are considering drafting questions and publishing them online with a guide to process the answer results. There will be a charge for this. The Board wants the physicians to KNOW the answers to these questions, not use the exams as a way to “get” them.

The next issue of note was a discussion on how to categorize complaints coming into the agency through Board members. Currently, such complaints are merely labeled “TMB” without identifiers on who specifically requested the investigation opened. This practice has been questioned by some. There is a concern that this is perceived as unethical. Ms. Robinson defended the practice.

There was a discussion that if Board members make complaints, should they be under TMB or under the Board member name. There was agreement that there is nothing wrong with a Board member reporting illegal behavior. Mr. Robert Simpson, the General Counsel, agreed that it was legal for Board members to do so.

Dr. Irvine Zeitler, the Board president, expressed that he has received numerous complaints from all over the state. It is his practice to encourage people who communicate to him to make the complaint themselves. Ms. Paulette Southard also stated that she also directly receives complaints. She states some of the people fear retribution, thus do not make the complaint themselves. Mr. Simpson agreed that it is a “cleaner situation” to have the person make the complaint, but if the person is just not willing, then it may be accept to have the Board member make the complaint.

Ms. Julie Attebury suggested sub-categorizing such complaints. For example, if staff opens a complaint based on information found during the course of an investigation versus a complaint made by a Board member.

The Board members directed staff to allow board members submitting complaints to decide on an individual complaints basis how to classify.

My Take:

1. I sincerely wish Ms. Robinson and Dr. Moore the best of luck. I hope they continue to do outreach and work with all parties, including the defense bar to make this system work for everyone.

2. I have no problems with the Board attempting to generate income. I especially like “giving” the answers to the jurisprudence test. It does not make any sense to play “hide the ball” with those questions, as it benefits everyone to know all the answers to the test. You know the answers to the test; hopefully the licensee will learn the law.

3. On the issue of Board members making complaints, m feeling is that the Board is currently suffering from a serious perception problems on this specific topic. The fact of the matter it does not matter if all complaints made by Board members are wholly legitimate, it does appear to be an abuse of power. As with many things in life perception is reality. Therefore, the Board members need to be careful in this regard. I believe that Dr. Zeitler is correct in his efforts to encourage people who complain to him to report their concerns to the Board. That is the proper method of dealing with this matter. Moreover, if a Board member has a legitimate, factually based concern regarding a practitioner, I do not have a problem with them reporting this. However, I believe the Board member should also sign a waiver to disclose that he or she made the complaint. That transparency will help the Board and the image of the Board. This will diminish the allegations of abuse of power. Note that I said legitimate, factually based concern. I strongly do not believe any Board member or Board staff should file a complaint against a licensee based solely on comments made by someone…that is hearsay, plain and simple. If there is objective evidence that’s one thing; subjective, unsupported comments are another. Whether that has been done or not in the past, I don’t honestly know. But is it the perception that it has that has hurt the image of the Board in the physician community. Transparency is the solution to this issue.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Perry Names A New Board Member and New DRC Member

Gov. Rick Perry has made two new appointments to the Texas Medical Board. The first is Scott Holliday, D.O. of University Park to the Texas Medical Board for a term to expire April 13, 2013. He replaces Dr. Roberta Kalafut.

Dr. Holliday is an anesthesiologist at Pinnacle Partners in Medicine and chairman of the Arlington Memorial Hospital Department of Anesthesiology. He is a member of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, Texas Osteopathic Medical Association, and Texas Medical Association. He is also an American Board of Anesthesiology Diplomate, and the Texas Society of Anesthesiologists District 2 State Delegate. Holliday received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Texas at Austin and a doctorate of osteopathic medicine from Kansas City University of Medicine and Bioscience. He completed his anesthesiology residency at the University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio.

John Guerra, D.O. was named to the Texas Medical Board District Four Review Committee for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2012. He replaces Bobby Howard.

Dr. Guerra is a board certified obstetrician/gynecologist, and a member of the American Osteopathic Association, Texas Osteopathic Medical Association, and American College of Osteopathic Obstetricians and Gynecologists. He is a member of St. Paul’s Catholic Church where he volunteers as a medical youth educator. Guerra received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Texas Pan American and a doctorate of osteopathy from the Texas College of Osteopathic Medicine.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

December TMB Board Meeting

TMB Executive Committee: 12/11/08

There was discussion on policies and procedures regarding individuals wanting to speak before the Board as there has been an increase the individuals wanting to address the Board. Ms. Robinson, the executive director, expressed a concern that if people are set on the Board’s agenda it may appear those people have been asked to appear and address the Board. Dr. Larry Price suggested a 30 minutes open forum, with a sign in sheet for those showing up the morning of. It was suggested that this time period go from 12:00 pm to 12:30pm. Those signing up to speak will provide a summary. This policy was approved.


Finance Committee: 12/11/08
Based on the report, there was approximately $100,000 left for the prior year’s budget. There may be some small outstanding receipts that need to pay from this reminder. Board staff estimated that in the first quarter of the fiscal year (which starts September 1st) the Board has spent 23% of its total budget.

Disciplinary Process Review Committee: 12/11/08
The Board heard four appeals of jurisdictional complaints, with one case re-opened. It also reviewed two non- jurisdictional complaints, with one opened to an investigation.
The Board discussed adopting a rule allowing doctors treating patients with STD’s to prescribe medication to their spouses and partners, as this is a public health issue. Some partners refuse to seek treatment due to lack of insurance and other reasons.

Dr. Melinda McMichael has query on limiting this to Gonorrhea and Chlamydia, as they do in other states. Ms. Robinson offers that the more specific you make the rule; the more often it will need to be changed. The Board motioned to adopt this new rule for publication.

Ms. Robinson thanked the Board members for their many nominations for expert panel suggestions, as the Board has experienced a shortage of experts willing to review cases. An appeal was sent out to all the specialty boards requesting nominations. Board member questioned whether it would help to advertise in a publication like Texas Medicine. Dr. Charles Oswalt mentioned that they needed to be careful of advertising in a widespread fashion as it could allow doctors with their own agenda to get their foot in the door and trying to change the way the board operates. Ms. Robinson will speak with Dr. Alan Moore, the Board’s Medical Director, regarding advertising for the panel positions. She is also considering having Dr. Moore begin an auditing program to review the panelist reports. Motion regarding approval of list of panel experts. One individual was removed from the list because his ex-wife was a lawyer on the board. Board approved the list with the one exception


Full Board Meeting: DECEMBER 12, 2008
Arrived 8:12 am
Directors Report: National Federation of State Medical Board -- Board wants to bring resolutions that would allow sharing of information between states. They specifically spoke about Applicants withdrawing applications and then applying in other state. The thinking is that if they withdraw, they may have something to hide and the state boards should be able to communicate this to each other.

Discussion on deleting the set of guidelines regarding anesthesiology assistants. This information will be removed. Board will continue to enforce Rule# 157 regarding physicians delegating to adequately trained assistants. This covers anesthesiologists as well.
Agenda item # 6 No order on this. A discovery motion was filed by Bob Simpson.
Consent Agenda – approved by motion.

Non Public Rehabilitation Orders. One Order was pulled and discussed. The Order was approved with deletion of a duplicate paragraph. Respondent changed specialty to ER medicine. Dr. Kalafut questioned whether this change was to avoid the stipulations of the Agreed Order. He passed the JP exam, and the Order is completed, but then could go back to the prior area of practice. Dr. Kalafut wanted to be sure that this individual would need to come before the Board in order to go back to previous area of practice. And if so, he would be under the original 5 year term of the Order.

8:30AM Senator Armbruster addresses the Board.

Various Proposed Orders were pulled, reviewed and discussed:

One Order was pulled by Paulette Southard regarding a doctor whose patient saw nurse practitioner 9 times from August to September. As x-ray done and found a tumor. Under the Order, the doctor can still able to supervise subordinates. Dr. McMichael proposes a fine for not adequately supervising the nurse practitioner and removing supervisory ability. It was discussed to place a three year restriction. It was proposed to issues a 3 years Order, removing supervisory delegation. Issue a $5,000 penalty and chart monitor. Also the Board directed staff to report the nurse practitioner to nursing board.

One Order was pulled by Julie Attebury as she did not see term for order. Respondent has a PIT and will have to present the order during the licensure process.

Ms. Southard pulled another Order. She questioned an Order regarding a physician who was already under an Order from 2005. She wanted to know why the new Order is only a one year term? Tim Turner explained that there was a specific reason for the one year term. The Order was approved with no changes.

Ms. Southard pulled another Order and expressed her opinion that there should be a fine. Only thing in the order is a requirement to comply with CME requirements. This was a from a fast track order. Sign this order and become compliant on CME immediately. The Order was approved without the change.

Ms. Southard asked about an Order in which a doctor prescribed medications to his son. She was not sure the whole story based on the Findings of Fact. She expressed a concern that when the Order is published in the newsletter, it brings up many questions because there is not enough detail. Rule 198 states -- standard of care – not allowed to prescribe to family member except in emergency and not to exceed 72 hours. It should clarify the board rule governs this controlled substance to a family member in amounts exceeding what is allowed. The drug in question was for ADHD and period was for one month. The Findings of Fact will delete that this was the doctor’s son and state it was an immediate family member and that the drug was on the controlled substance list. This doc was previously disciplined by the board. The first order was for CME violation. Several board members wanted to include the rule violated in the Findings of Fact. Ms. Robinson pointed out it was cited in Conclusions of Law.

Dr. Jose Benevides questioning the period of time for family prescriptions in the current Rule. Costs are same for 3 days of medications versus 30 days of medication. Ms. Robinson directed staff look into changing rule.

All Administrative Orders passed.

All Modification Requests passed.
All Nunc Pro Tunc Orders passed.

All Mediated Settlement Agreed Orders passed.

All Termination of Suspension Orders passed.

The Board reported that if they receive funding , the Board will continue with education outreach for physicians. The report sent to the Board members includes all notes from the town hall meetings. They did 13 meetings in 14 weeks and will not do that again as that was too many. The Board expressed that communication is important and continue to work at outreach. The format will change in the future. Plan to continue to pursue different communication efforts. It was expressed that the Board should take an active approach with informing the medical community.

In terms of outreach, it was express to make regular written submissions through TMA and county newsletters. It was opined as almost no one reads the disciplinary items on the Boards newsletter. Establishing better communication with different stakeholders and having information available at health fairs. Ms. Robinson asked Board Members to thoroughly read the report and give feedback. Dr. McNeese offered that TMA has blast email, which might be an avenue to use for educational items.

Dr. McMichael was named to be liaison during this legislative session.

479 physicians’ licensure applications were approved.

RULE CHANGES
Chapter 163.5 163.5 approved

Chapter 165 161.5 & 161.1 approved

Chapter 166 166.2 & 166.6 will be republished in final form with changes. Robert Simpson, general counsel, recommends passing. Republishing language of established rule approved.

169 – 169.7 approved

Chapt 173 approved

Chapt 178 Complaints approved

Chapt 179 approved

Chapt 180 approved

Chapt 182 Use of Experts – Public comments Elizabeth Naugle. Asked Board to consider changing statutes to include Experts from outside of Texas. She will bring the issue to Legislature. Approved

Chapt 187 approved

Chapt 190 disciplinary guidelines Board looks at AMA guidelines, suggested that they should publish this , but AMA asked them not to, as it can be used as a sword by patients.
Ms. Robinson suggested they approved everything but point # 8 and make adjustments to that point with input from the stakeholders. Approved 190.1 and 190.14.

Motion on 190.8 to direct staff to make amendments

Chapt 192

Changes delete 191.2 which talks about standards for anesthesia services, level one. Regarding certain drugs being available in every O.R. in pre-measured doses. The problem and feedback is they do not come in premeasured form. Dr. Kalafut suggests change “pre-measured doses” to “have on hand” . Specific stakeholder group came up with the initial set of guidelines, but now that it has been implemented, changes need to be made. Will be removing pre-measured. Approved

Shirley Pigott, MD asked to address the Board. Elizabeth Naugle asked to address the Board.

Sorry for Not Writing

Ok. I have not written in a while. Sorry about that. I am going to try to get back into the habit of writing. My goal is no less than two posts per week. I should have information on the last Board meeting up soon.

Friday, December 12, 2008

President Resigns; New President Named

This morning the President of the Texas Medical Board, Roberta Kalafut, D.O. of Abilene resigned both as President and member of the Board. Dr. Kalafut served as a member of the Board for many years spending a significant amount of time and energy devoted the Board. She is resigning to spend more time with her family. Dr. Kalafut will remain involved with the Board as member of District Review Committee.

Irvin Zeitler, D.O., of San Angelo has been named the new President of the Board. Dr. Zeitler is a board certified family practice physician at Shannon Medical Center, where he serves as Vice President of Medical Affairs. He graduated from the University of Texas at Austin with a B.S. in Pharmacy and earned his medical degree from the University of North Texas Health Science Center at Fort Worth. He completed his family practice residency at Texas Tech. He previously practiced in Stamford, Texas. Dr. Zeitler has served on the District Review Committee since 1988, having been appointed by three different governors. He was appointed to the Texas Medical Board last year.

Dr. Zeitler is an intelligent and thoughtful individual. I have always found him to be open, straight-forward and well prepared. I wish him the best of luck in this new position with the Board.

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

New Appointments to the Board

Gov. Rick Perry has appointed David Baucom of Sulphur Springs to the Texas Medical Board for a term to expire April 13, 2009. Mr. Baucom is president of Baucom Insurance Services Inc. He is a member of the Independent Insurance Agents of Texas, a founding director of First American Mortgage Company and a past director of First American Bank. He is also a past member of the Sulphur Springs City Council, past mayor of Sulphur Springs and president of the Sulphur River Basin Authority. Baucom served in the U.S. Army National Guard. He received a bachelor’s degree from Baylor University. He replaces Melinda Fredricks of Conroe.

Mr. Baucom previous served a number of years on the District Review Committee of the Board. The District Review Committee members are used to support the Board members. This is especially true in the disciplinary process as these members of used at ISCs on a regular basis.
Mr. Baucom is an extremely kind, knowledgeable, and well-prepared individual. I have always found him thoughtful and inquisitive. I do not always agree with Mr. Baucom on his decisions, but I always have respect for them as he never comes to a decision lightly.

Mr. Perry also appointed nine members to Texas Medical Board District Review Committees.

Sharon J. Barnes of Port Lavaca is the human resource leader at the Dow Chemical Company. She is national secretary of the National Organization of Black Chemists. She is also a past mayor-pro tempore and city council member of the city of Lake Jackson. Barnes received a bachelor’s degree from Baylor University and a master’s degree from the University of Phoenix. She is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2012. This is her second appointment as a District Review Committee Member.

Wendy Prater Dear of Tomball is an attorney in private practice. She is a member of the State Bar of Texas and Houston Bar Association. She is also a member of the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo, Board of Vocational Nurse Examiners and Northwest Family YMCA Board of Directors. Dear received a bachelor’s degree and a law degree from Baylor University. She is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2014. This is her first full appointment as a District Review Committee Member, she filled an expired term.

Charles Stiernberg of Bellaire is a physician in private practice. He is a fellow in the American Academy of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery, and a member of the Texas Medical Association and Harris County Medical Society. Stiernberg received a bachelor’s degree from Louisiana State University, a master’s degree from the University of Houston and a medical degree from the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston. He is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2014.

Frank Wellborne of Houston is a clinical rheumatologist in private practice. He is a member of the American and Texas Medical associations and an American College of Rheumatology fellow. Wellborne received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Missouri and a medical degree in osteopathic medicine from Des Moines University. Wellborne is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2012. This is his third appointment as a District Review Committee Member.

Kathy C. Flanagan of Houston is a self-employed psychiatrist. She is a member of the Houston Medical Forum, American Psychiatric Association and National Medical Association. She is also a volunteer at the DePelchin Children’s Center. Flanagan received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Texas at Austin and a medical degree from the University of Texas Medical School. She replaces Kevin Smith of Houston for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2010.

Harry K. Wallfisch of Galveston is a professor of anesthesiology at the University of Texas Medical Branch. He is a member of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, Society of Critical Care Medicine and an American Board of Anesthesiology diplomat. Wallfisch received a bachelor’s degree from Tulane University and a medical degree from Louisiana State University. He replaces Richard Strax of Houston for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2012.

Janet Tornelli-Mitchell of Dallas is a staff physician at Cooper Clinic. She is a member of the Dallas County Medical Society and Texas Medical Association. Tornelli-Mitchell received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Texas at Austin and a medical degree from the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston. She is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2014. This is her second appointment as a District Review Committee Member. She is also a former Board member.

Penny Angelo of Midland is a past member of the Texas Board of Examiners of Psychologists. She is chair of Neighbors Against Burglary and Drugs. Angelo received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Texas at Austin. She is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2014. This is her second appointment as a District Review Committee Member. She is also a former Board member.

David W. Miller of Abilene is president and CEO of Hendrick Home for Children. He is past president of the Southwestern Association of Executives of Homes for Children. Miller received a bachelor’s degree from Hardin-Simmons University, and a master’s degree and doctorate degree from Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. He is reappointed for a term to expire Jan. 15, 2012. This is his second appointment as a District Review Committee Member.

Monday, December 8, 2008

STANDARD OF CARE CASES

I have found a large increase in the number of complaints regarding the standard of care. It appears to me that the vast majority of the complaints opened do lead to full investigations. According to staff that I have discussed this with, the Board wants the Board consultants to review each complaint. I understand the rationale, but I believe it can be done better. The Board does employ nurse investigators and should, in my opinion, give them great discretion to evaluate some of these initial complaints. Some of these initial complaints should be screened in cases where the standard of care is met, based on both the medical records and supporting information, to ensure it does not rise to the level of a full investigation. This would be a win for both the Board and the doctor. The doctor would not have to bare the stress and expense of an investigation. The Board would not waste its resources and time on an investigation its own staff knows is within the standard of care. There are many members of the staff that are well qualified, experienced and able to do this. Moreover, all closures are reviewed by the Board members, so this will balance this process. This would be a win-win.